Soupdog
SIGN IN

Dal Makhani

10 hr 54 min · 46 min active · makes ~3.75 l · Medium

Creamy black kidney beans simmered with plum tomatoes, cumin, and black cardamom in a rich, aromatic sauce. Serves 4.

Ingredients
0/22 gathered · 4 servings
250g
60g
2,500ml
200g
6clove
30g
400g
15ml
60g
1tsp
2piece
3piece
1piece
1piece
1tsp
1tsp
1tsp
30g
2tsp
1tsp
100ml
10g
Tools
16 items
Serveware
1 item
Procedure
48 steps
1 of 48

Tip the whole black urad dal into the large bowl.

Whole black urad dal · 250 g
⏱ 10s
ResultWhole black urad dal
2 of 48

Add the dried red kidney beans to the bowl with the dal.

Dried red kidney beans · 60 g
⏱ 10s
ResultWhole black urad dal and dried red kidney beans
3 of 48

Pour cold water over the dal and beans until they are well submerged.

Water · 1,000 ml
⏱ 15s
ResultWhole black urad dal and dried red kidney beans and water
4 of 48

Leave the dal and beans to soak at room temperature for at least 8 hours or overnight.

⏱ 8 hr
ResultSoaked dal and kidney beans
5 of 48

Tip the soaked dal and beans into the colander and drain away the soaking water.

⏱ 20s
ResultSoaked dal and kidney beansused in step 7
6 of 48

Pour the fresh water into the large heavy-based saucepan.

Water · 1,500 ml
⏱ 10s
ResultWater
7 of 48

Add the drained dal and kidney beans to the saucepan.

⏱ 10s
ResultWater and soaked dal and kidney beans
8 of 48

Bring the water to a vigorous boil over high heat and boil hard for 10 minutes, skimming off any foam that rises to the surface.

⏱ 10 min
ResultBoiled dal and beans
9 of 48

Reduce the heat to low, partially cover the pan, and simmer gently for 1 hour 30 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the dal and kidney beans are completely soft and beginning to break down.

⏱ 1 hr 30 min
ResultTender dal and beansused in step 42
10 of 48

Halve the onion and peel away the papery outer skin.

White onion · 200 g
⏱ 30s
ResultPeeled onion
11 of 48

Finely chop the peeled onion into small, even pieces.

⏱ 1 min
ResultFinely chopped white onion
12 of 48

Sweep the finely chopped onion into the small bowl and set aside.

⏱ 10s
ResultFinely chopped white onionused in step 30
13 of 48

Crush each garlic clove firmly with the flat of the knife to loosen the skin, then peel away the skin.

Garlic · 6 clove
⏱ 30s
ResultPeeled garlic cloves
14 of 48

Mince the peeled garlic cloves into a fine paste by rocking the knife back and forth over them.

⏱ 40s
ResultFinely minced garlic
15 of 48

Scrape the minced garlic into the second small bowl.

⏱ 10s
ResultFinely minced garlic
16 of 48

Scrape the skin off the ginger with the edge of a peeler.

Fresh ginger · 30 g
⏱ 20s
ResultPeeled fresh ginger
17 of 48

Mince the peeled ginger into a very fine paste by chopping repeatedly until almost smooth.

⏱ 40s
ResultMinced ginger
18 of 48

Scrape the minced ginger into the bowl with the garlic and stir them together.

⏱ 10s
ResultFinely minced garlic and minced gingerused in step 32
19 of 48

Roughly chop the plum tomatoes into coarse chunks, keeping the juices.

Plum tomatoes · 400 g
⏱ 1 min
ResultRoughly chopped plum tomatoes
20 of 48

Scrape the chopped tomatoes and all their juices into the medium bowl.

⏱ 10s
ResultRoughly chopped plum tomatoesused in step 40
21 of 48

Pour the neutral oil into the second large heavy-based saucepan.

Neutral oil · 15 ml
⏱ 5s
ResultNeutral oil
22 of 48

Add the butter to the saucepan with the oil.

Butter · 30 g
⏱ 5s
ResultNeutral oil and butter
23 of 48

Set the pan over medium heat and let the butter melt and begin to foam, swirling the pan once.

⏱ 1 min
ResultHot butter and oil
24 of 48

Add the cumin seeds to the hot fat.

Cumin seeds · 1 tsp
⏱ 5s
ResultHot butter and oil and cumin seeds
25 of 48

Drop in the bay leaves.

Bay leaf · 2 piece
⏱ 5s
ResultHot butter and oil mixture
26 of 48

Add the whole cloves.

Cloves · 3 piece
⏱ 5s
ResultHot butter and oil mixture
27 of 48

Add the black cardamom pod.

Black cardamom pods · 1 piece
⏱ 5s
ResultHot butter and oil mixture
28 of 48

Add the cinnamon stick.

Cinnamon stick · 1 piece
⏱ 5s
ResultHot butter and oil mixture
29 of 48

Fry the whole spices over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the cumin seeds darken and the mixture smells fragrant, about 30 seconds.

⏱ 30s
ResultBloomed whole spices
30 of 48

Tip in the finely chopped onion.

⏱ 10s
ResultBloomed whole spices and finely chopped white onion
31 of 48

Cook the onion over medium heat, stirring frequently, for 15 minutes until it is deeply golden and soft throughout.

⏱ 15 min
ResultDeeply golden onion
32 of 48

Add the minced garlic and ginger to the pan.

⏱ 10s
ResultDeeply golden onion and finely minced garlic and minced ginger
33 of 48

Stir the garlic and ginger into the onion and cook for 2 minutes until the raw smell fades.

⏱ 2 min
ResultFragrant garlic-ginger base
34 of 48

Add the ground coriander to the pan.

Ground coriander · 1 tsp
⏱ 5s
ResultFragrant garlic-ginger base and ground coriander
35 of 48

Add the ground cumin.

Ground cumin · 1 tsp
⏱ 5s
ResultFragrant garlic-ginger base and ground coriander and ground cumin
36 of 48

Add the Kashmiri red chilli powder.

Kashmiri chilli powder · 1 tsp
⏱ 5s
ResultFragrant garlic-ginger base and ground coriander mixture
37 of 48

Stir the ground spices into the onion mixture and cook for 1 minute, stirring constantly, until they smell toasty.

⏱ 1 min
ResultSpiced onion masala
38 of 48

Add the tomato paste and stir it into the spiced onion.

Tomato paste · 30 g
⏱ 10s
ResultSpiced onion masala and tomato paste
39 of 48

Cook the paste over medium heat, stirring constantly, for 2 minutes until it darkens and the oil begins to separate at the edges.

⏱ 2 min
ResultDarkened tomato-spice paste
40 of 48

Pour in the roughly chopped plum tomatoes with all their juices.

⏱ 10s
ResultDarkened tomato-spice paste and roughly chopped plum tomatoes
41 of 48

Cook the tomatoes over medium heat, stirring and breaking them down with the spoon, for 10 minutes until the masala is thick and the oil rises to the surface.

⏱ 10 min
ResultThick tomato masala
42 of 48

Pour the tender dal and beans, along with their cooking liquid, into the tomato masala pan.

⏱ 20s
ResultThick tomato masala and tender dal and beans
43 of 48

Season with the salt and stir everything together.

Salt · 2 tsp
⏱ 10s
ResultBean and thick tomato masala mixture
44 of 48

Simmer uncovered over the lowest heat for 1 hour, stirring every 10 minutes and mashing some of the dal against the side of the pan to thicken the sauce naturally.

⏱ 1 hr
ResultSlow-simmered dal makhani base
45 of 48

Sprinkle in the garam masala and stir it through.

Garam masala · 1 tsp
⏱ 10s
ResultSlow-simmered dal makhani base and garam masala
46 of 48

Add the butter in one piece.

Butter · 30 g
⏱ 5s
ResultSlow-simmered dal makhani base and garam masala and butter
47 of 48

Pour in the double cream.

Double cream · 100 ml
⏱ 10s
ResultSlow-simmered dal makhani base and garam masala mixture
48 of 48

Stir the butter and cream into the dal over low heat for 5 minutes until they are fully absorbed and the sauce is glossy and rich.

⏱ 5 min
ResultFinished dal makhani
Total Time10 hr 54 min
Serving
  1. Ladle the dal makhani into a warm serving bowl.
  2. Scatter fresh coriander leaves over the top to finish. The bay leaf, cloves, black cardamom pods and cinnamon stick are there for flavour; don't eat them.
Nutrition
per serving
Estimated · pre-cooking · 92% ingredients covered
NutrientPer serving
589kcal
22g
27g
14g
60g
10g
8g
1,338mg
Ingredients0/22
Tools0/13